Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Restaurant Industry's Biggest Competitor Is No Longer Another Restaurant

 


The Grocerant Niche is eating into restaurant occasions. Some brands are adapting. Others are protecting yesterday's business model while tomorrow's customers walk away according to Steven Johnson Grocerant Guru® at Tacoma, WA based Foodservice Solutions®.

Let's stop pretending the restaurant industry's competitive problem is simply inflation, labor costs, interest rates, private-equity valuations or consumers becoming more price-conscious.

Those are real challenges. But they are not the entire story.

The bigger problem is that consumers are changing where, when, how and why they purchase prepared food. And while some restaurant brands are responding, far too many established operators remain committed to protecting legacy brand values, legacy footprints, legacy menus and legacy channel strategies.

Here is the uncomfortable truth: Consumers are not waiting for restaurant executives to approve their changing habits.

They are already migrating.


The Grocerant Guru® has been identifying and following this convergence of grocery and restaurant foodservice since Foodservice Solutions® introduced the Grocerant Niche in 1996 through its Call Them Grocerants.

Today, the evidence is difficult to dismiss.

The grocery store is not just where consumers purchase ingredients. The convenience store is not just where consumers buy gasoline, candy and beverages. Both are increasingly competing for prepared-food occasions that restaurants once considered their own.

And the numbers are getting bigger.

1. Grocery is not knocking on the restaurant industry's door. It is already inside.

Consider the Food Industry Association's (FMI) Power of Foodservice at Retail research.

More than half of U.S. households—56%—combine home preparation with foods prepared outside the home for dinner at least once a week.

Read that again.

Consumers are not necessarily choosing between cooking dinner and buying dinner. They are combining prepared foods with ingredients from their own kitchens.

This is precisely the kind of consumer behavior that makes traditional restaurant-industry segmentation increasingly irrelevant.

The same FMI research identifies prepared foods as an increasingly integrated part of household meal routines. Consumers want flexible solutions, meal bundles, heat-and-eat sides and family-size options.

In other words, grocery retailers are not simply selling a sandwich or rotisserie chicken. They are helping consumers solve dinner.

The 2025 FMI report offered another revealing statistic: The percentage of consumers substituting deli-prepared foods for restaurant meals more than doubled, from 12% in 2017 to 28% in 2025.

More than one-quarter of consumers were already reporting that behavior.

That is not a small competitive inconvenience. It is customer migration.


Grocerant Guru verdict: Restaurant executives who still consider supermarket prepared foods a secondary competitor are not paying attention to the marketplace. They are looking at their competitors through a rearview mirror.

2. Convenience stores are becoming foodservice businesses. Restaurants should be nervous.

The National Association of Convenience Stores (NACS) released its 2025 industry results in April 2026.

Here are the numbers restaurant executives should have posted in their boardrooms:

·       U.S. convenience-store foodservice and merchandise sales reached $341.2 billion in 2025, up 1.7% from 2024.

·       Foodservice represented 28.5% of convenience-store in-store sales.

·       Foodservice contributed 38.9% of in-store gross profit dollars.

·       Prepared food represented 73.9% of convenience-store foodservice sales.

That last number matters.

Convenience retailers are not simply adding more packaged snacks. Prepared food is becoming the center of their foodservice proposition.

Compare that with 2005, when foodservice represented just 11.9% of convenience-store in-store sales.

The change is enormous.

The convenience industry has spent two decades expanding its foodservice capabilities. Restaurants that dismissed convenience retailers as gasoline businesses may have missed the development of an entirely different competitive threat.


This is what customer migration looks like.

It does not always announce itself with a restaurant closure. Sometimes it shows up as a customer purchasing lunch somewhere else three days a week.

Grocerant Guru verdict: Convenience stores have recognized that food creates trips, transactions and profit. Restaurant operators should ask themselves whether their own formats are creating enough reasons for customers to visit.

3. The winners are translating legacy brands into new occasions

Not every established restaurant company is standing still.

Some are beginning to understand that preserving brand equity does not require preserving every aspect of the original business model.

But let's separate genuine adaptation from another limited-time offer.

Benihana Express: A legacy experience without the legacy footprint

Benihana Express, developed by The ONE Group Hospitality, is one of the more interesting concepts emerging from the 2026 Restaurant Finance & Development Conference.

The proposed format takes the flavors and food associated with Benihana into a premium fast-casual operation of approximately 800 to 1,000 square feet.

The company estimates net build costs of $400 to $500 per square foot.

The concept removes the traditional teppanyaki tables and bar, translating the brand into a smaller, more convenient format.

This is the right strategic question: Does the customer want the food and flavors of Benihana without necessarily wanting the time, price or formality of a traditional teppanyaki occasion?

That is a smart question to ask.

It is also an acknowledgment that the consumer may want the brand's food without wanting its original operating format.

However, a proposed franchise concept is not yet proof of success. Franchisee returns, repeat visits, incremental customer acquisition and food quality will determine whether the strategy works.

The lesson: Preserve the brand's recognizable food promise. Do not force consumers to preserve the original occasion.


Chipotle: A reminder that the customer still responds to product relevance

Chipotle offers another important lesson.

In its first quarter of 2026, Chipotle reported a 0.5% comparable-sales increase, surprising analysts who had expected a decline.

Transactions increased 0.6%, and restaurant visits increased 5.8%, according to Reuters' reporting.

The company's Recipe for Growth initiative included operational improvements, marketing and menu activity such as the return of Chicken Al Pastor.

It also offered smaller, lower-priced choices, including a $3.50 taco and a $3.80 high-protein cup.

There is a lesson here for restaurant executives who insist that menu innovation must always mean larger portions, higher checks or premium-priced products.

Sometimes consumers want a smaller portion. Sometimes they want a snack. Sometimes they want protein without purchasing a full entrée.

Chipotle's results suggest that food relevance and occasion flexibility can help bring customers back.

But there is a caution: Restaurant-level margins declined to 23.7% from 26.2%, illustrating that traffic improvement must be accompanied by disciplined operating economics.

The lesson: More customer visits are valuable, but profitable customer visits are the objective.

Taco Bell: Innovation is more than another coupon

Taco Bell demonstrates another form of adaptation.

Yum! Brands reported 7% same-store sales growth for Taco Bell in the fourth quarter of 2025 and the full year.

That performance deserves attention in an environment when many restaurant operators are struggling to generate traffic.

Taco Bell has historically invested heavily in menu innovation, cultural relevance, limited-time offerings and collaborations.

It has demonstrated that a brand can retain a recognizable identity while continuously refreshing the reasons customers visit.

But the real takeaway is not simply to launch more products.

It is to understand that consumers need reasons to reconsider a brand.

A legacy menu that rarely changes may be comforting to management, but it can become predictable to customers.

The lesson: Heritage can attract attention. Relevance earns the next visit.

Source: Yum! Brands, 2025 fourth-quarter and full-year results.

4. Some legacy brands are confusing brand recognition with consumer demand

Now comes the tougher conversation.

A recognizable brand name does not guarantee consumer relevance.

A national footprint does not guarantee traffic.

A franchise system does not guarantee profitable unit economics.

And a familiar menu does not guarantee that consumers still consider the brand a compelling solution.

The restaurant industry has a long history of rewarding expansion. Executives were celebrated for adding units, entering new markets and increasing average checks.

But the consumer marketplace has changed.

Restaurant Business reported during the 2026 Restaurant Finance & Development Conference that industry restaurant traffic was down approximately 21% compared with 2018.


That is an extraordinary warning.

When an industry loses that many visits, management should not simply celebrate higher average checks.

It should question whether its formats, menus, pricing and customer propositions remain competitive.

The industry cannot keep charging more for fewer visits and call that a sustainable growth strategy.

Five legacy-brand mistakes that are becoming increasingly expensive

1. Defending the dining room instead of defending the occasion.

Consumers do not owe restaurants a sit-down visit. They want solutions for breakfast, lunch, dinner, snacks and beverages. If the dining room is the only way a brand can deliver its product, it may be limiting its own addressable market.

2. Treating grocery prepared food as inferior competition.

This is strategic arrogance. Grocery retailers are investing in prepared meals, ingredients, meal bundles and convenience. Consumers increasingly view those offerings as legitimate alternatives to restaurant meals.

3. Confusing loyalty with customer acquisition.

A loyalty program can reward existing customers, but it cannot guarantee new customers. Restaurant brands must create reasons for people who have migrated elsewhere to reconsider their offerings.

4. Protecting menu traditions at the expense of new occasions.

A signature burger, sandwich, pizza or entrée may remain important. But what about smaller portions, protein-forward snacks, portable meals, heat-and-eat products and beverages? Consumers have more occasions than traditional restaurant menus sometimes acknowledge.

5. Protecting channel boundaries.

A restaurant company that refuses to consider grocery partnerships, retail distribution, alternative footprints or new pickup models is voluntarily limiting its reach.

The brand is not the building.

The brand is the consumer's perception of the promise being delivered.

5. Six customer-migration opportunities legacy restaurant brands should pursue

The Grocerant Niche is not about abandoning restaurants. It is about expanding the ways brands participate in consumers' food decisions.

Here are six opportunities that deserve serious investment.


Opportunity 1: Signature food beyond the restaurant.

Take recognizable menu items into refrigerated, heat-and-eat or ready-to-eat formats. A restaurant's signature flavor profile could reach consumers through grocery retail and other foodservice outlets.

Opportunity 2: Smaller portions and more flexible occasions.

Develop snacks, mini-meals, protein-forward offerings and beverages. Not every consumer wants a full meal, and not every occasion deserves a full entrée price.

Opportunity 3: Grocery partnerships.

Explore branded meal components, prepared foods and co-developed products. Grocery retailers already have the shopper relationship and retail infrastructure. Restaurant brands can contribute food credibility and distinctive flavors.

Opportunity 4: Convenience-store distribution.

A recognizable restaurant product could create new consumer access through convenience retail. Think portable breakfast, lunch, snacks and late-day food occasions.

Opportunity 5: Smaller physical formats.

Benihana Express is an example of the question worth asking: Can a brand reach more consumers with a smaller, more efficient format?

But smaller must not mean lower quality. The customer experience still matters.

Opportunity 6: Own the in-between occasions.

Restaurants have historically emphasized breakfast, lunch and dinner. But the consumer's day includes midmorning snacks, afternoon hunger, post-workout food, after-school occasions and late-night consumption.

Those occasions represent incremental opportunities, not just opportunities to discount existing meals.


6. Six migration threats legacy brands should stop ignoring

The opportunities are real. So are the threats.

1.       Grocery substitution: Prepared deli foods replace restaurant meals, with FMI reporting that substitution more than doubled between 2017 and 2025.

2.       Convenience-store encroachment: Prepared food is now a major contributor to convenience-store sales and gross profits.

3.       Value erosion: Consumers increasingly question whether a fast-casual meal delivers enough value compared with a grocery purchase or a sit-down restaurant.

4.       Customer-base contraction: Higher average checks can conceal the loss of customers and visits.

5.       Operational rigidity: Large footprints, complicated menus and inflexible labor models can make it harder to adapt to changing occasions.

6.       Brand complacency: Familiarity can become a liability when management assumes yesterday's customer loyalty guarantees tomorrow's demand.

These threats are interconnected.

A consumer who finds a better lunch solution at a grocery store may eventually change the entire weekly food-purchasing routine.

That consumer may not be lost to the restaurant category. The consumer may simply be lost to a particular restaurant brand.

That distinction is critical.


7. Investors should demand a customer-migration scorecard

If I were sitting across the table from a restaurant CEO, franchise executive or private-equity investor, I would want answers beyond average unit volumes and same-store sales.

I would want to see evidence of customer relevance.

Here are seven measures worth adding to the investment conversation:

Unique customer growth: Whether the brand is attracting new people.

Transaction growth: Whether consumers are visiting more often in total.

New occasion penetration: Whether the brand is winning additional dayparts.

Off-premise mix: Whether it is adapting to changing consumption patterns.

Food quality and satisfaction: Whether the product earns repeat consideration.

Incremental channel sales: Whether new formats create genuinely additional demand.

Contribution margin by occasion: Whether the new business is economically sustainable.

One important distinction: Digital orders, loyalty memberships and app downloads are not substitutes for unique customer growth.

A brand can have millions of app users and still fail to attract new consumers.

Likewise, off-premise sales growth is not automatically incremental growth if those sales simply replace existing dining-room transactions.

The objective should be profitable customer acquisition and incremental food occasions.

8. The restaurant industry needs a new definition of brand protection

Here is the challenge for industry insiders.

If grocery prepared foods are taking more meal occasions, convenience stores are improving prepared-food quality, and restaurant traffic is under pressure, what exactly are legacy brands protecting?

Their menus?

Their dining rooms?

Their logos?

Their historical positioning?

Their franchise territories?

Those things may have value. But they are not the customer.

The customer is the asset.

Foodservice Solutions® identified the Grocerant Niche because consumers were already demonstrating that they did not respect the artificial boundaries between restaurants and grocery stores.

Today, that behavior is increasingly mainstream.

The restaurant industry's next winners will recognize that the competition is not limited to the company across the street.

It is every retailer, restaurant, food manufacturer and foodservice operator competing for the same consumer, the same dollar and the same eating occasion.

The future belongs to brands that understand the consumer's changing definition of convenience, quality, portability and value.

The future does not belong to the brand with the longest history.

It belongs to the brand that remains relevant.

And to those executives who still believe that protecting legacy brand values means protecting legacy business models, I have a question:

Are you protecting your brand's future, or are you protecting the very assumptions that are causing consumers to migrate away from it?

That is not a rhetorical question.

It is an investment question.


Three Insights from the Grocerant Guru®

1. Customer migration is not a threat to the foodservice industry. Ignoring customer migration is the threat. Consumers will continue to purchase prepared food. The question is whether restaurant brands, grocery retailers or convenience operators will capture those occasions. Follow the consumer, not the traditional industry channel.

2. Brand heritage is an ingredient, not the entire recipe. A recognizable name, signature flavor and established reputation have value only when translated into today's consumer expectations. Protect the promise. Change the delivery. Innovate the format. Expand the occasion.

3. The next generation of restaurant growth will be measured by customer relevance, not restaurant count. More locations do not automatically mean more demand. More promotions do not automatically mean more customers. The brands that win will attract new consumers, capture incremental occasions and deliver a compelling Price Value Service Equilibrium across restaurant, grocery and convenience channels.

The Grocerant Guru® bottom line: Stop asking how to get yesterday's customers to visit one more time. Start asking where tomorrow's customers are eating, what they are buying and why. Then build a business model that gives them a reason to choose your brand.

Are you ready for some fresh ideations? Do your food marketing ideas look more like yesterday than tomorrow? Interested in learning how our Grocerant Guru® can edify your retail food brand while creating a platform for consumer convenient meal participation, differentiation and individualization?  Email us at: Steve@FoodserviceSolutions.us or visit: us on our social media sites by clicking one of the following links: Facebook,  LinkedIn, or Twitter



No comments:

Post a Comment