Showing posts with label Grocerant Guru. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Grocerant Guru. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2026

McRib, McMarketing and the Meat of the Matter: Why McDonald’s Should Not Have to Apologize for a Brand Name

 


The Grocerant Guru® Steven Johnson examines the McRib lawsuit, the value of product differentiation, trademarked food identities, and why familiar food concepts with a twist are what keep brands relevant.

There is a fundamental misunderstanding about food marketing at the center of the lawsuit against McDonald’s over its McRib sandwich: A branded food product is not necessarily a literal description of the ingredients or the specific cut of meat used to make it.


That distinction matters.

McDonald’s did not introduce a menu item called the Premium Pork Rib Sandwich. It introduced the McRib®. A distinctive, trademarked product name that has become part of the company's food marketing vocabulary and consumer recognition.

The McRib is not being sold as a rack of barbecue ribs placed between two pieces of bread. It is a seasoned, boneless pork sandwich with barbecue sauce, onions and pickles, presented in a familiar rib-like shape.

That is product development. That is branding. That is differentiation.

And, from the perspective of the Grocerant Guru®, that is precisely what successful food marketers should be doing.

The lawsuit deserves scrutiny, but so does the larger question: Should food companies be penalized because consumers recognize a branded product name and associate it with a familiar food experience, even when the product is a creative interpretation rather than a literal version of that food?

The McRib has been around since 1981. Its trademark was registered in 1985 for a sandwich. That is more than four decades of product identity, consumer exposure and brand development.

On October 30, 2026, a federal judge in Chicago declined to dismiss the central consumer deception claims in a proposed class action. That ruling allows litigation to continue; it does not establish that McDonald's deceived consumers or that the company is liable.

McDonald's has maintained that the allegations distort the facts and that it has been transparent about the sandwich's ingredients.

I agree with the underlying marketing principle McDonald's is defending: A brand name is an asset, a product identity is a promise of an experience, and differentiation should not be confused with deception.

First, understand what the McRib actually is

McDonald's describes the McRib as seasoned boneless pork dipped in tangy barbecue sauce, topped with slivered onions and pickles, and served on a toasted homestyle bun.

Its own product FAQ explains that the company starts with ground pork and uses a press to form the patty into a shape resembling a rack of ribs.

McDonald's even explains why it does this: It's fun.

Let's be clear about the distinction.

·       It is pork.

·       It is real meat.

·       It is boneless.

·       It is ground and formed into a distinctive shape.

·       It is not represented on the product page as a serving of whole pork ribs.

The distinction between ground pork and a whole-muscle pork rib cut is important. Consumers should be able to understand what they are purchasing. But a shaped pork product does not become something other than pork simply because it is pressed into a recognizable form.

The plaintiffs allege that the product's name, shape and advertising lead consumers to expect actual rib meat. McDonald's disputes the allegations, including claims about the use of heart, tripe and stomach. Those ingredient allegations should not be treated as established facts.

The real food marketing question is whether the name McRib, in its total branding and disclosure context, constitutes a promise about the specific anatomical cut of pork.

That is a very different question from whether McDonald's has a recognizable branded pork sandwich.

Six strong food marketing reasons this lawsuit should be dropped

1. McRib is a registered product identity, not a promise of a particular pork cut

McDonald's registered the MCRIB trademark in 1985, with first commercial use dating to 1981. The registration identifies the goods as a sandwich for consumption on or off the premises.


That history matters.

McRib is not simply a generic menu description. It is a branded product identity developed, marketed and recognized over decades.

Consider Burger King's WHOPPER®. The company protects the Whopper name as a trademark. Consumers recognize a branded sandwich, not a technical specification of every ingredient or its dimensions.

The McRib deserves the same fundamental recognition as a branded food product.

A trademark does not excuse false advertising, but neither should a trademarked name automatically be interpreted as a literal ingredient declaration.

2. McDonald's tells consumers it is boneless pork

This is one of the strongest points in McDonald's defense.

Its official product description uses the words "seasoned boneless pork." Its FAQ explains that the pork is ground and pressed into a rib-like shape.

Those are meaningful disclosures.

The company is not advertising a bone-in rack of ribs. It is selling a boneless pork sandwich with a distinctive shape and barbecue flavor profile.


Food marketers have an obligation to communicate accurately. But consumers also have a responsibility to consider the actual product description rather than assigning an ingredient list to a brand name.

There is a difference between creating an appealing product identity and making a false factual statement.

3. Food marketing has always used familiar language with creative twists

Let's look beyond the McDonald's drive-thru.

Consider the Seattle Seahawks and the famous 12th Man.

The Seahawks used the 12th Man identity to describe their fans and the powerful atmosphere those fans create. But the expression is not a literal count of players on the field.

More importantly, the 12th Man is a registered Texas A&M trademark. The Seahawks negotiated licensing agreements to use it. They subsequently shifted toward the expression 12s.

The marketing lesson is that a name can represent an experience, an identity and an emotional connection rather than a literal physical description.

Other examples reinforce the point:


The brand promises wings through its famous marketing slogan, not actual wings. It sells an energy drink, not a zoological product.

Its 2025 company-reported figures show 13.969 billion cans sold in 178 countries, an increase of 10.2% over 2024. That is a powerful example of a distinctive brand identity becoming a global commercial asset.


The product uses the familiar language, appearance and eating experience of meat while being made from plants. Impossible Foods reported in its 2024 marketing materials that 90% of its consumers identified as meat eaters.

Impossible Foods

That is familiarity with a twist: consumers recognize the food experience, even though the underlying product is different.

Burger King used its established Whopper identity to introduce a plant-based alternative. The familiar sandwich format made a different protein proposition easier for consumers to understand.

These examples are not identical legal situations. They illustrate an important commercial principle: successful food marketing frequently builds on familiar consumer language while introducing something different.

Why should McDonald's be denied that same creative latitude?

4. Product differentiation is essential to surviving in a crowded food marketplace

Think about the competitive landscape.

McDonald's competes with burger chains, barbecue restaurants, convenience stores, grocery delis, prepared-food departments, delivery kitchens and an expanding selection of ready-to-eat meals.

A pork sandwich that looks like a rack of ribs, carries a distinctive name and delivers a recognizable barbecue flavor creates separation.

That separation is valuable.

If every restaurant had to market products using only literal descriptions of their ingredients, much of the creative language that helps consumers navigate food choices would disappear.

Brands need recognizable names. They need distinctive shapes. They need signature sauces, flavor profiles, packaging and memorable product experiences.

The McRib combines several of those elements.

It is not just pork on a bun. It is a recognizable McDonald's product with its own identity.

5. Familiarity reduces the work consumers must do when making food decisions

Food purchasing is often a low-involvement decision. Consumers are hungry, busy, price-conscious and looking for something familiar that offers a little excitement.

A recognized product name helps simplify that decision.

The McRib's periodic return is part of its marketing proposition. Scarcity, anticipation and familiarity work together.

McDonald's has been selling the sandwich periodically since 1981. That is a remarkable product lifecycle in an industry where menu items are constantly introduced, modified and discontinued.


The product has become more than a sandwich. It has become an occasion.

Consumers discuss its return, anticipate its availability and share their experiences. That creates earned attention and gives McDonald's a reason to reconnect with customers.

The McRib's recognizable identity does marketing work before the customer even reaches the counter.

6. The lawsuit risks confusing a consumer's preferred ingredient with a legally required product specification

This is where the argument deserves particular attention.

Some consumers may prefer pork rib meat. Others may prefer pork shoulder. Still others may care most about the sauce, texture, convenience, price or overall taste.

Those preferences are legitimate.

But the fact that one pork cut commands a different wholesale price than another does not automatically establish that a branded pork sandwich is deceptively marketed.

The plaintiffs argue that customers expected premium rib meat and paid more because of that expectation. That is an allegation, not a proven economic injury or established finding.

McDonald's defense should focus on the complete consumer-facing message: the trademarked product name, the description of seasoned boneless pork, the ingredient disclosures, the FAQ explanation and the actual sandwich.

If the company has disclosed the relevant facts and has not falsely claimed to sell a whole-muscle rib cut, the lawsuit should not turn a creative product design into consumer fraud.

The food marketing distinction is simple: A brand can promise a recognizable experience without promising that every component is identical to the traditional food that inspired it.

The bigger issue: Don't punish food innovation


7. There is another issue that deserves attention.

Food companies are being asked to innovate, differentiate, deliver value and give consumers reasons to return.

Yet when they create something recognizable but different, they can find themselves defending the very marketing creativity that made the product successful.

That is a troubling direction.

The food industry has always evolved through reinterpretation.

Hamburgers have been reinvented countless times. Chicken sandwiches have become a competitive category of their own. Plant-based burgers borrow the appearance and language of traditional beef burgers. Grocery delis create restaurant-inspired meals. Convenience stores turn familiar restaurant flavors into handheld, portable products.

That is how food marketing works.

The McRib is another example of taking a familiar food concept, applying a different production technique and building a distinctive branded product around it.

I would argue that McDonald's should defend that principle vigorously.

There is one important legal qualification: the October 30 ruling means the case is allowed to proceed, not that McDonald's has lost on the merits. The judge found the plaintiffs' interpretation of the name and advertising sufficiently plausible at this early stage. The ultimate question of deception remains unresolved.

My position is that the complete product disclosures and the longstanding branded identity provide a strong basis for McDonald's to prevail. If discovery confirms those disclosures and the absence of misleading factual claims, the case should be dismissed.


Three Grocerant Guru® insights: Familiarity with a twist wins

Insight 1: Consumers buy experiences, not ingredient dictionaries.

Consumers want recognizable flavors, convenient formats, satisfying portions and products that fit their lifestyles. Brands must communicate what they are selling, but they should not be forced to abandon creative product development because a familiar name inspires a particular food association.

Insight 2: Differentiation is a competitive necessity, not a marketing luxury.

If your product looks, tastes, feels and is named exactly like everyone else's, why should consumers choose you? McDonald's created a recognizable pork sandwich with a distinctive shape, barbecue flavor and trademarked identity. That is differentiation. Brands that fail to differentiate eventually compete primarily on price.

Insight 3: The future belongs to brands that are familiar but never static.

Consumers are dynamic, not static. Their expectations, eating occasions, budgets and food preferences evolve. Successful brands retain the familiar elements consumers appreciate while introducing new twists that encourage trial, repeat purchases and customer migration.

The Grocerant Niche has demonstrated for decades that consumers move between restaurants, grocery stores and convenience stores looking for food that delivers on price, time, flavor and convenience.

McDonald's understands something important: Sometimes the best way to introduce something new is to make it feel familiar.

The Grocerant Guru® bottom line

McDonald's did not call its product a rack of pork ribs. It created the McRib®, a trademarked, boneless pork sandwich made from real pork, formed into a distinctive shape and marketed with a familiar barbecue flavor profile.

There is a difference between misleading consumers and giving consumers a new interpretation of a familiar food.

Food marketers should be held accountable for truthful product communication. They should not be punished simply for being creative.

My position: Defend the McRib, defend product differentiation and defend the ability of food brands to create familiar experiences with a twist.

At Foodservice Solutions®, we identify, quantify, and qualify new retail food segment opportunities—from menu innovation to brand integration strategies. We help you stay ahead of industry shifts with fresh insights and consumer-driven solutions. Connect with us on social media: Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter

Ready to Find Your Next Success Clue? We specialize in outsourced food marketing and business development ideations—helping brands seize opportunities in food retail, technology, and menu innovation.

Reach out today: Steve@FoodserviceSolutions.us



Sunday, October 25, 2026

The Global Grocerant Opportunity: Fresh, Fast, Flavorful Food Is Redefining How Consumers Eat

 


Consumers do not need more complexity in their lives. They need better ways to solve everyday food decisions. That simple truth continues to reshape retail foodservice, restaurants, grocery stores, convenience stores, and the broader food industry according to Steven Johnson Grocerant Guru® at Tacoma, WA based Foodservice Solutions®.

Since Foodservice Solutions® identified the Grocerant Niche in 1996, the central premise has remained consistent: consumers want fresh-prepared, Ready-2-Eat (RTE) and Heat-N-Eat (HnE) foods that combine flavor, convenience, portability, and value. What has changed is the number of businesses competing to satisfy those needs.

Today, a consumer can purchase a prepared meal from a restaurant, grocery deli, convenience store, warehouse club, or another retailer expanding its foodservice offerings. Consumers do not necessarily organize these choices into industry categories. They decide what sounds good, what fits their schedule, what they can afford, and how much effort they want to invest in getting a meal on the table.


That is the opportunity at the heart of the Grocerant Niche.

The Data Are Clear: Prepared Food Is Becoming Part of the Everyday Meal Solution

Consider what recent industry research tells us about the changing food landscape.

According to FMI—The Food Industry Association’s 2024 Power of Foodservice at Retail research, approximately 70.7% of households regularly purchased foodservice products from retail stores. The research also found that 59% of shoppers wanted the opportunity to purchase combinations of prepared foods, including main courses, side dishes, and desserts, at a discounted set price. These findings demonstrate the importance of making meals easier to assemble and purchase. (FMI, 2024.)

The message for retailers is straightforward: convenience is not limited to selling a sandwich or a single prepared entrée. It includes helping consumers complete a meal.

In 2025, FMI reported that the share of consumers choosing grocery deli-prepared foods instead of restaurant meals had more than doubled, rising from 12% in 2017 to 28% in 2025. More than half of Americans, 53%, were also combining deli-prepared foods with items from their own kitchens to create meals. (FMI, 2025.)

By October 2026, FMI's Power of Foodservice at Retail research found that 56% of households combined home preparation with foods prepared outside the home for dinner at least once a week. The report also identified an opportunity for retailers to offer meal bundles, heat-and-eat side dishes, family-size options, and combinations of prepared and grocery items. (FMI, 2026.)

These are not merely statistics about deli sales. They illustrate a larger shift in how consumers participate in meal preparation.

Consumers can prepare an entire dinner, buy a fully prepared meal, or combine the two. They can purchase a protein and prepare the sides, pick up a complete family meal, or select several individual items that reflect different tastes and dietary preferences.

The winning proposition is not necessarily a fully prepared meal. It is the right amount of preparation for the consumer's needs at that moment.

Convenience Has Become a Food Marketing Imperative


Convenience is often discussed as though it simply means faster checkout, drive-thru service, or delivery. The Grocerant Guru® sees a broader opportunity.

Convenience means reducing the effort required to decide what to eat, find the desired food, purchase it, transport it, and serve or consume it.

The National Restaurant Association's 2024 State of the Restaurant Industry report found that 52% of consumers considered restaurant takeout an essential part of their lifestyle. By April 2025, the Association reported that nearly 75% of restaurant traffic occurred through off-premises channels, including takeout, drive-thru, and delivery. Its 2025 research also found that speed, good service, easy-to-use ordering technology, value offers, and loyalty programs were important elements of repeat business. (National Restaurant Association, 2024 and 2025.)

The implications extend well beyond restaurants.

A grocery store with an attractive deli but no coherent meal solution may lose a consumer to a restaurant offering an easy family bundle. A convenience store with excellent coffee but limited fresh-food choices may miss lunch and dinner occasions. A restaurant that excels at flavor but makes ordering, pickup, or reheating unnecessarily complicated may surrender repeat business to a competitor.

The opportunity is to make the complete food experience easier without compromising quality.

That means investing in food packaging that travels well, clear product information, reliable availability, sensible portion choices, convenient ordering, and menus designed for real-life eating occasions.

Portable food is not just food that fits in a container. It is food designed around the consumer's destination, schedule, appetite, and circumstances.


Differentiation Means Familiar Food With a Twist

One of the enduring principles of effective food marketing is that differentiation does not always require inventing an entirely new food.

Often, it means taking something familiar and making it more relevant.

Consumers recognize sandwiches, salads, bowls, pizza, chicken, breakfast items, snacks, and comfort foods. Retailers can differentiate those familiar choices through seasoning, ingredients, preparation, portion size, packaging, accompaniments, or a distinctive flavor profile.

A familiar meal can become more compelling with a globally inspired sauce, a different protein, a regional flavor, a plant-forward ingredient, or a convenient format that makes it easier to eat on the move.

Individualization matters, too. Some consumers want a complete meal, while others want to select their own sides or add a preferred snack. Some prioritize protein; others seek vegetarian options, lighter meals, or familiar comfort food.

The lesson is not that every retailer needs an enormous menu. It is that every retailer needs a clear food proposition with enough flexibility to serve different needs.

Food marketing must begin with the consumer and the occasion—not simply with the products a company already knows how to sell.


Price Matters. Value Is the Bigger Equation.

In a competitive food market, convenience alone will not guarantee success. Consumers still compare prices, portions, perceived quality, and the total effort required to obtain a meal.

The National Restaurant Association's 2025 off-premises research identified value offers as an important purchase motivator. Its findings reinforce the need to make the benefit of an offer clear rather than assuming consumers will pay more simply because a product is convenient.

For Grocerant Niche operators, value can take several forms:

  • Price value: A competitive price, meaningful promotion, or well-designed meal bundle.
  • Quality value: Freshness, flavor, ingredient quality, and dependable execution.
  • Time value: Less shopping, preparation, cooking, and cleanup.
  • Choice value: Options that fit different appetites, budgets, and preferences.
  • Social value: Food that makes it easier to share a meal with family, friends, or coworkers.
  • Portability value: Food that fits the consumer's schedule and destination.

The lowest-priced item does not automatically offer the greatest value. A reasonably priced meal that tastes good, travels well, and requires little additional work can be a stronger proposition than a cheaper item that leaves the consumer to purchase several more ingredients.

Retailers should measure value through the entire meal occasion, not just the shelf price of an individual product.

Retail Foodservice Is Becoming a Destination

The latest data point to another opportunity: retailers can build a reputation around a signature food offering.

FMI's 2026 research found that only about one-third of shoppers considered their primary grocery store known for a particular deli-prepared food item. Rotisserie chicken, roasted chicken, sandwiches, sushi, and pizza were among the products shoppers associated with grocery foodservice departments. The report also found that half of same-day dinner decisions occurred between 3 p.m. and 7 p.m. (FMI, 2026.)

That creates two significant marketing opportunities.

First, retailers can establish a signature item that gives consumers a reason to visit. A recognizable product can become a food destination, encourage repeat purchases, and provide a platform for complementary products.

Second, retailers can align their merchandising with the moments when consumers are making food decisions. Dinner solutions displayed and promoted when shoppers are deciding what to eat may be more relevant than products presented without regard to the occasion.

A retailer does not need to be everything to everyone. It needs to be particularly good at solving selected food needs while offering enough variety to encourage additional purchases.

This is where a disciplined foodservice strategy can turn the deli, prepared-food counter, or grab-and-go department into a destination rather than simply another department in the store.


The Consumer Does Not See Industry Silos

Consumers are not required to remain loyal to a single food channel.

The same person might buy breakfast at a convenience store, lunch from a restaurant, a snack at a grocery store, and dinner from a warehouse club or another retailer. The next day, those choices may change.

The consumer's decision is shaped by the occasion, appetite, budget, schedule, location, and perceived value. Brand preference matters, but it competes with all those other considerations.

This is why the Grocerant Niche is best understood as a consumer-driven food marketplace rather than a single retail category.

Restaurants, supermarkets, convenience stores, warehouse clubs, and other retailers increasingly compete for overlapping meal occasions. Each has different operational strengths, but the competitive question is similar: Can the business offer the food the consumer wants, when it is needed, at a price that feels worthwhile?

For operators and suppliers, this creates opportunities for collaboration, product development, co-branding, new distribution arrangements, and foodservice partnerships. It also demands a willingness to reconsider established assumptions about who owns a customer or a meal occasion.

Consumers migrate. Businesses must adapt.


Is Your Food Marketing Looking Ahead—or Looking Back?

The growth of prepared-food choices does not mean every retailer or every prepared-food product will succeed. Execution matters. Food safety, freshness, consistent quality, labor, waste, packaging, and profitability remain essential.

Nor should every retailer attempt to copy the same menu or the same service model. A convenience store, supermarket, restaurant, and warehouse club have different operating environments and customer expectations.

The strategic opportunity is to identify unmet consumer needs and create food solutions that fit the business's strengths.

Ask yourself:

  • Does your food proposition solve a specific consumer problem?
  • Are your RTE and HnE products designed for convenience, flavor, portability, and quality?
  • Can customers easily combine prepared foods and grocery items to complete a meal?
  • Do your price points communicate meaningful value?
  • Do you have signature foods that can build consumer awareness and repeat visits?
  • Are you competing for the consumer's next meal occasion—or relying on yesterday's channel boundaries?

At Foodservice Solutions®, we believe the next phase of food marketing belongs to companies that understand the evolving consumer and develop products, partnerships, and experiences around the way people actually eat.

The opportunity is not simply to sell more prepared food. It is to make convenient meal participation easier, more appealing, and more relevant.

The Grocerant Niche continues to offer a useful framework for understanding that opportunity. The businesses that put the consumer first, deliver consistently, and make the value proposition clear will be better positioned to earn the next purchase.



Are you looking a customer ahead?

For food marketing strategy, retail foodservice ideation, partnership development, and ways to strengthen your brand's position in the Grocerant Niche, visit FoodserviceSolutions.us.

Steven Johnson is the Grocerant Guru® at Foodservice Solutions®, Tacoma, Washington.

Three Insights from the Grocerant Guru®

1. Consumers migrate to solutions, not silos.
The next meal occasion belongs to the business that best combines flavor, convenience, quality, and price—not necessarily the business that has traditionally owned the channel.

2. Fresh-prepared food is a platform for differentiation, not just another product category.
Signature items, meal bundles, portable formats, and customizable combinations give retailers and restaurant operators practical ways to build relevance, encourage repeat purchases, and earn a larger share of the consumer's food spending.

3. Make the meal easier, and make the value obvious.
Consumers want more than speed. They want food that fits their schedule, budget, appetite, and lifestyle. The brands that remove friction while delivering dependable flavor and quality will be better positioned to win the next purchase.