The Restaurant Finance & Development Conference exposes
a bigger problem than tight credit: Customer migration, lost traffic and legacy
thinking are challenging the industry's growth model
The
restaurant industry recently gathered in Las Vegas for the 2026 Restaurant Finance & Development
Conference (RFDC), November 9–11, at the Wynn. Lenders, private-equity
investors, restaurant executives, franchise operators and financial advisers
came together to discuss capital, valuations, development, profitability and
the future of restaurant companies.
But
perhaps the most important takeaway wasn't about financing.
It
was about relevance.
The
industry is confronting a difficult combination: declining restaurant traffic,
consumer financial pressure, expensive operations, restricted lending, cautious
private-equity investment and increasingly aggressive competition from grocery
stores, convenience stores and independent foodservice operators according to Steven Johnson Grocerant Guru® at
Tacoma, WA based Foodservice Solutions®.
The
question industry insiders should be asking is not simply where they can find
capital to grow.
It
is whether the business model they want to finance is still aligned with where
consumers want to spend their food dollars.
That
distinction matters.
According
to conference observations reported by Restaurant Business, industry same-store
sales were tracking toward approximately 1.7% growth for 2026. However, average
check—not increasing customer visits—is doing much of the work. More troubling,
restaurant traffic was reported to be down 21% compared with 2018.
Think
about that number.
An
industry can report positive comparable sales while losing a substantial
portion of its customer visits. Higher menu prices, larger checks and inflation
can create the appearance of growth without creating stronger consumer
relationships.
Revenue
growth and customer growth are not interchangeable.
And
investors should know the difference.
1. The private-equity slowdown is a symptom, not the
disease
One
of the conference's more sobering conversations concerned restaurant
transactions.
Cristin
O'Hara, Bank of America's head of restaurants, explained that private-equity
firms have found more attractive returns in other sectors. Ashish Seth of
Harrington Park Advisors described a buyer market that has contracted because
many investment firms remain committed to restaurant portfolios they cannot
exit at their desired valuations.
This
should concern more than restaurant owners seeking an acquisition.
When
capital becomes selective, investors start asking harder questions about
sustainable demand, cash flow, unit economics and the ability to generate
profitable customer visits.
A
familiar logo is not a financial strategy.
A
40-year-old brand is not automatically a 40-year-old opportunity.
And
a franchise system with hundreds of locations is not necessarily a growth
business if its customer base is shrinking.
The
industry has spent decades equating expansion with success. More units, more
territories, more franchisees and more real estate were often treated as
evidence of brand strength.
That
equation needs updating.
A
restaurant company that opens 50 new locations without demonstrating that it
can attract new customers may simply be multiplying its exposure to an outdated
business model.
Investors
should be financing consumer relevance, not nostalgia.
2. Twenty-one percent fewer visits: The number executives
cannot afford to ignore
The
reported 21% decline in restaurant traffic since 2018 deserves more attention
than another discussion about menu pricing.
Why?
Because
traffic is the physical evidence of consumer choice.
Consumers
have more ways to satisfy food and beverage occasions than ever before. They
can purchase prepared meals at grocery stores, pick up restaurant-quality food
at convenience stores, order through third-party delivery, use meal kits,
purchase ready-to-eat snacks or assemble dinner from several retailers.
They
are not necessarily abandoning foodservice.
They
are migrating between foodservice channels.
That
is a critical distinction.
The
Grocerant Niche, identified by Foodservice Solutions® in 1996 through its Call
Them Grocerants work, recognizes the convergence of grocery and restaurant
foodservice. Today, that convergence extends well beyond supermarket delis.
Consumers
do not organize their food decisions around industry categories, corporate
reporting segments or franchise classifications.
They
organize them around needs:
·
What can I eat right now?
·
What will work for dinner tonight?
·
What fits my budget?
·
What can I take with me?
·
What offers the best combination of
taste, quality, convenience and value?
·
What makes my limited time easier to
manage?
The
restaurant industry may still be measuring competition by restaurant category.
Consumers are measuring it by the available solution.
That
is why a convenience-store fresh-food program can take an occasion from a QSR.
A supermarket prepared meal can replace a casual-dining visit. An independent
restaurant can attract customers who believe its food quality justifies the
price.
The
competitor is whoever wins the consumer's next food occasion.
3. Value is not a coupon. Stop confusing price with value.
Another
important RFDC conversation centered on the changing definition of value.
Revenue
Management Solutions CMO Jana Zschieschang emphasized that consumers
increasingly evaluate the experience, including food and service, rather than
simply the price point.
That
is an important distinction, but the industry should take it further.
Value
is an equation, not a discount.
The
Grocerant Guru's Price Value Service Equilibrium considers price, product
quality, social relevance and portability as contributors to consumer-perceived
value.
A
$5 meal that disappoints is not a bargain.
A
$12 meal that delivers excellent food, appropriate portions, convenience and an
experience worth repeating may be a better value.
But
there is a warning here for operators.
Consumers
are not obligated to accept higher prices simply because a brand believes its
food, service or heritage deserves a premium.
Restaurants
must earn that premium every time.
The
days of assuming that consumers will pay more because a brand has been around
for generations are numbered.
Value
must be demonstrated at the transaction level.
That
means food quality, portion integrity, speed, accuracy, hospitality, packaging,
portability and convenience must work together.
It
also means understanding local markets. A national pricing strategy that
ignores differences in household income, competition and consumer demand can
undermine both traffic and margins.
4. The competition has moved beyond the restaurant
industry's traditional boundaries
Technomic's
Rich Shank and Placer.ai's R.J. Hottovy brought attention to the growing
competition from convenience stores and supermarkets.
This
should not be treated as a passing observation.
It
is a structural change in the food marketplace.
Grocery
retailers have invested in prepared foods, fresh meals, grab-and-go offerings
and foodservice experiences. Convenience retailers have improved food quality,
expanded menus and made prepared food a more credible part of their business.
Independent
restaurants, meanwhile, can offer perceived authenticity, quality and value
that national chains sometimes struggle to deliver.
The
competitive set has expanded.
Yet
too many restaurant executives continue to evaluate performance through a
narrow lens: QSR against QSR, fast casual against fast casual, casual dining
against casual dining.
That
is brand protectionism disguised as competitive analysis.
The
consumer does not care whether a competitor belongs to the same restaurant
segment. If a grocery retailer solves dinner better, it wins dinner.
If
a convenience store delivers a satisfying breakfast sandwich faster, it wins
breakfast.
If
an independent operator offers a more compelling meal for the same money, it
wins consideration.
The
restaurant industry's historical channel boundaries are not consumer
boundaries.
5. Loyalty programs cannot manufacture customer demand
Perhaps
the most revealing conference discussion concerned customer acquisition versus
frequency.
Chris
O'Cull of Baird examined 335 million visits across 1,260 restaurants and eight
chains. His observation was that customer frequency tends to vary by concept
and occasion. A coffee customer may visit daily, while a polished casual-dining
customer may visit only a few times annually.
His
conclusion: restaurants need more customers, not simply more visits from the
customers they already have.
That
should challenge the way many brands allocate marketing dollars.
Loyalty
programs, mobile applications, push notifications and personalized promotions
can help retain customers. But they cannot automatically create a new customer
base.
A
brand can become extremely efficient at communicating with the same customers
while becoming progressively less relevant to everyone else.
Chili's
was cited as an example of customer-count growth of approximately 17% since
2017, accompanied by a similar increase in total visits.
That
reinforces a fundamental point: customer count is a growth engine.
The
next question should be how to attract customers who have migrated to other
foodservice options.
Not
every lost customer will return because of a loyalty reward.
Some
have changed routines. Some have changed budgets. Some have discovered better
alternatives. Others simply no longer see a compelling reason to visit.
Winning
them back requires a better proposition, not another app notification.
6. The conference's own announcements reveal where the
market is heading
Several
company announcements and conference observations offer a useful look at how
operators are responding.
Krispy
Kreme: Smaller footprints and more access
Krispy
Kreme announced its Hot Light Express prototype, a smaller-footprint concept
intended to extend access to its fresh, hot Original Glazed doughnuts. The
company described the project as an early test, not a systemwide rollout.
That
is an interesting development.
The
brand is exploring how to bring a recognizable product experience to consumers
through a different physical format.
The
strategic question is whether smaller, more convenient access points can create
incremental occasions rather than merely redistribute existing sales.
The
ONE Group: Benihana Express
The
ONE Group promoted Benihana Express as a franchise opportunity. Its proposed
footprint is approximately 800 to 1,000 square feet, with estimated net build
costs of $400 to $500 per square foot.
The
concept takes the flavors associated with Benihana and puts them into a premium
fast-casual format without the traditional teppanyaki tables and bar.
That
is a meaningful adaptation of a legacy dining experience.
It
recognizes that consumers may want the food without necessarily wanting the
time, cost or formality of the original occasion.
But
the real test will be execution: Can the concept preserve enough of the brand's
appeal while delivering attractive franchise economics, food quality and
convenience?
Technology
and site selection: Better data, better decisions
Conference
discussions also highlighted AI, customer sentiment, labor data and site
selection.
Kalibrate's
November 11 conference recap described how Miguel's Jr. was bringing customer
data, sentiment and labor information together to support more informed
decisions. It also highlighted the importance of current trade-area data rather
than relying on outdated market assumptions.
CapitalSpring's
Jim Balis discussed new restaurant investments that can require approximately
$750,000 to $1.5 million per location.
When
that much capital is committed to a single restaurant, opening in the wrong
trade area becomes an expensive mistake.
These
developments point toward a more intelligent approach to expansion: smaller
formats, more precise location decisions, better customer intelligence and
concepts that adapt to changing occasions.
But
technology is only useful when it helps a business understand and serve
consumers better.
An
AI-enabled restaurant that still offers the wrong food, at the wrong price, in
the wrong format, is simply a more technologically advanced version of an
outdated business.
7. Legacy brand values must evolve—or become liabilities
Here
is where industry insiders should become uncomfortable.
Brand
heritage has value. Recognition has value. Familiarity has value. But none of
those things guarantees future relevance.
Too
many established restaurant companies confuse protecting their brand with
protecting their past.
They
protect menu traditions that no longer meet changing needs. They protect real
estate formats that restrict convenience. They protect channel strategies that
ignore grocery and convenience competition. They protect pricing structures
that make their products less accessible. They protect organizational silos
that prevent them from seeing the entire food marketplace.
That
is not brand stewardship.
It
is brand stagnation.
A
brand's promise should remain recognizable, but its delivery must evolve.
Consider
the opportunities:
·
Menu migration:
Take signature flavors into portable meals, snacks and beverages.
·
Format migration:
Expand beyond traditional dining rooms into smaller footprints, pickup and
other convenient access points.
·
Occasion migration:
Compete for breakfast, afternoon snacks, lunch, dinner and late-night
consumption rather than depending on a single daypart.
·
Channel migration:
Partner with grocery, convenience and other retail platforms where appropriate.
·
Customer migration:
Attract new demographic, lifestyle and value-seeking customer groups rather
than relying exclusively on established loyalists.
·
Technology migration:
Use data and AI to understand changing demand, improve forecasting and make
customer acquisition more effective.
These
are not simply marketing tactics.
They
are business-model decisions.
The
industry needs to stop asking whether consumers will return to the way they
used to eat.
It
needs to ask how to earn a place in the way consumers eat today.
8. The real investment question: Are we financing customer
migration?
The
RFDC conversations about capital, valuations, traffic, value, customer
acquisition, AI and smaller restaurant formats are interconnected.
They
are not separate challenges.
They
are all expressions of one larger marketplace transformation.
The
restaurant industry has spent years optimizing existing locations, raising
average checks, introducing loyalty programs and expanding established
concepts. Those activities can be useful, but they cannot substitute for a
compelling consumer proposition.
A
restaurant company should be able to answer five questions before asking
investors to finance its next phase of growth:
1. Are
we attracting more customers, or simply collecting more money from fewer
visits?
2. What
food occasions are consumers giving us, and which are they giving to
competitors?
3. Does
our menu reflect current consumer demand for quality, convenience, portability
and value?
4. Can
our physical format and operating model adapt to changing lifestyles and
household economics?
5. Are
our investments creating incremental demand, or simply adding capacity to an
already crowded marketplace?
If
management cannot answer those questions with credible evidence, perhaps the
next investment should not be another restaurant.
Perhaps
it should be a new way to reach the customer.
The
restaurant industry's future will not be determined by how well it preserves
yesterday's business model.
It
will be determined by how successfully it migrates with the consumer.
The
Grocerant Guru® perspective: Capital follows opportunity. Consumer
demand creates opportunity. Brands that understand customer migration will have
a better chance of attracting both customers and capital. Those that cling to
legacy brand values while ignoring changing consumer behavior may discover that
their greatest competitor is not another restaurant company. It is their own
unwillingness to change.
Three Insights from the Grocerant Guru®
1.
Traffic is the truth; average check can disguise the problem.
A restaurant brand cannot price its way indefinitely around declining customer
counts. Sustainable growth begins with earning more customers and more food
occasions.
2.
Value is bigger than price. Consumers evaluate the complete
proposition: food quality, portion, service, social relevance, convenience and
portability. The winners will deliver a better Price Value Service Equilibrium,
not simply another discount.
3.
Customer migration is the new growth strategy.
Stop defending channel boundaries and legacy formats. Follow the consumer
across restaurants, grocery, convenience and emerging foodservice occasions.
The next generation of successful restaurant brands will not merely protect
their heritage; they will translate it into relevance for the next generation
of customers.
For international corporate
presentations, educational forums, or keynotes contact: Steven Johnson
Grocerant Guru® at Tacoma, WA based Foodservice Solutions. His extensive experience as a multi-unit
restaurant operator, consultant, brand / product positioning expert and public
speaking will leave success clues for all. For more information visit
www.GrocerantGuru.com , www.FoodserviceSolutions.us or call 1-253-759-7869





















