Showing posts with label Pizza Hut. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pizza Hut. Show all posts

Monday, October 19, 2026

Pizza’s Next Battle: Scale, Sales, Customer Frequency and the Toppings Consumers Crave

 


When you’re hungry for pizza, what makes you choose one over another—and what makes you come back? Is it the toppings you crave, the quality you can taste, the price that fits your budget, or the convenience of getting dinner on the table without another hassle?

Smithfield Culinary’s new research suggests consumers have strong opinions: 46% say toppings matter most, and 79% have gone out of their way to try a particular pizza. That tells the pizza business something important: consumers aren’t just buying a pie; they’re choosing an experience they believe is worth their money, time and appetite.

For national chains, neighborhood pizzerias, grocery delis and convenience stores alike, the challenge is clear: What makes your pizza the one consumers want tonight—and the one they choose again tomorrow?

From the perspective of the Grocerant Guru®, pizza's next chapter will be shaped by the intersection of brand scale, average unit volume, customer frequency, ingredient quality, convenience, portability and perceived value. Operators that connect those elements to evolving consumer expectations will be better positioned to capture the next meal occasion.


1. The Seven Pizza Chains: Size, Sales and Average Unit Volume

Understanding the competitive landscape requires looking at more than the number of locations. Systemwide sales indicate total sales generated across a chain's restaurant network, while average unit volume (AUV) measures average annual sales per location. Neither figure, on its own, reveals profitability or customer loyalty.

Industry reporting from the 2026 QSR 50 and PMQ's 2025 Pizza Power Report provides a basis for comparing major U.S. pizza chains. The figures below reflect different reporting sources and dates, so they should be treated as an industry snapshot rather than a perfectly standardized ranking.

Seven major pizza chains

1. Domino's

·       Reported U.S. systemwide sales: $9.953 billion.

·       Reported average unit volume: $1.385 million.

·       Reported U.S. locations: 7,186.

Domino's leads this group in reported U.S. sales and AUV. Its combination of digital ordering, delivery, carryout and national brand recognition supports a high-volume operating model. The challenge is to keep translating convenience and familiarity into repeat orders as consumers face changing budgets and more prepared-food choices.

2. Pizza Hut

·       Reported U.S. systemwide sales: $5.094 billion.

·       Reported average unit volume: $808,000.

·       Reported U.S. locations: 6,307.

Pizza Hut retains a substantial national footprint. However, reported unit declines and lower AUV than Domino's make restaurant productivity and the performance of existing locations important issues. A large footprint is an advantage only when locations continue to meet consumer expectations and generate sustainable sales.


3. Little Caesars

·       Estimated U.S. systemwide sales: approximately $3.700 billion.

·       Estimated average unit volume: approximately $950,000.

·       Reported U.S. locations: 4,374.

Little Caesars competes through affordability, convenience and a recognizable value proposition. Its larger location count relative to Papa John's demonstrates that a chain can build scale around a different combination of price, service and customer expectations.

4. Papa John's

·       Estimated U.S. systemwide sales: approximately $3.702 billion.

·       Estimated average unit volume: approximately $1.124 million.

·       Reported U.S. locations: 3,294.

Papa John's has fewer reported locations than Little Caesars but higher estimated AUV. That distinction illustrates why unit count alone is not an adequate measure of competitive strength. Sales productivity, average order value, operating costs and customer frequency all matter.

The reported sales estimates for Papa John's and Little Caesars are nearly identical, so the small difference should not be interpreted as a meaningful competitive gap.

5. Marco's Pizza

·       Reported U.S. systemwide sales: $1.094 billion.

·       Reported average unit volume: $832,000.

·       Reported U.S. locations: 1,184.

Marco's represents an important middle-market competitor. It has a smaller footprint than the four largest chains but enough scale to compete nationally. Its opportunity is to combine recognizable brand positioning with product differentiation and local execution.


6. Papa Murphy's

·       Reported U.S. locations: approximately 1,127 in the cited location ranking.

·       Comparable systemwide sales and AUV: not established in the cited figures.

Papa Murphy's take-and-bake model serves a different meal occasion from conventional delivery and carryout. Consumers finish preparing the pizza at home, allowing the brand to compete for the family dinner occasion through a different service model.

7. Godfather's Pizza

·       Reported U.S. locations: approximately 583 in the cited location ranking.

·       Comparable systemwide sales and AUV: not established in the cited figures.

Godfather's Pizza remains a recognizable competitor with a smaller footprint than the leading national chains. Its position reinforces the importance of distinguishing between national scale and the ability to maintain relevance within particular markets.

The sales and AUV figures above draw on the 2026 QSR 50 and PMQ's 2025 Pizza Power Report. Because reporting dates, estimates and location definitions can vary, the figures for these seven brands should not be interpreted as a single, audited ranking across every measure.


What about customer frequency?

Customer frequency is a critical part of pizza economics, but public information does not provide a consistent, current, apples-to-apples frequency ranking for all seven chains.

Industry surveys have reported that Americans consume pizza several times a month. Those category-level figures demonstrate pizza's recurring role in the American diet, but they do not establish how frequently customers visit a particular chain.

For operators, that distinction matters. A chain can increase AUV through more frequent orders, larger baskets, higher prices or a combination of these factors.

Without customer-level frequency, average ticket, repeat-purchase and retention data, sales figures alone cannot explain the complete consumer story.

The Grocerant Guru® perspective is straightforward: measure how often customers return, not just how many locations you operate.

2. Smithfield Culinary's Findings: Seven Food Marketing Signals

Smithfield Culinary's Guest Check survey, conducted among 2,000 U.S. adults who order restaurant pizza at least monthly, examines what consumers say makes a great pizza. The findings provide useful direction for menu development and marketing, although stated preferences do not automatically translate into purchases or repeat visits.

Here is my assessment of seven important food marketing signals in the findings.

1. Toppings are the leading product differentiator

Forty-six percent of respondents identify toppings as the most important component of a great pizza. Crust ranks first for 30%, sauce for 13%, and cheese for 11%.

Grocerant Guru® rating: A

This is a strong menu-development signal. Toppings give operators an opportunity to create recognizable signature products, limited-time offers and premium combinations without rebuilding an entire menu.

However, the other 54% remind operators that toppings are not everyone's first priority. Crust quality, sauce and cheese remain essential parts of the product experience.

2. Ingredient quality beats piling on more

Thirty-seven percent of respondents prioritize topping quality, compared with 18% who prioritize quantity.

Grocerant Guru® rating: A

This is an important value proposition. Consumers do not necessarily want the heaviest pizza; they want a pizza whose ingredients justify its price.

Better seasoning, appealing textures, consistent portions and recognizable ingredient quality may create more value than simply adding more meat. Operators should test whether customers will pay a premium for those attributes and whether the resulting sales justify the added costs.

3. Destination pizza can create brand advocacy

Nearly eight in ten respondents say they have made a special effort to try a particular pizza, including taking detours, making day trips, waiting in lines or incorporating pizza into travel plans. One-quarter report traveling at least 25 miles to eat pizza or visit a particular pizza restaurant.


Grocerant Guru® rating: A

A compelling pizza can become the destination rather than just the dinner solution.

Operators should develop products worth talking about, signature offerings that customers remember, and regional identities that consumers cannot easily reproduce elsewhere. The opportunity is not to make every pizza expensive; it is to give consumers a reason to choose yours.

4. Pepperoni remains a powerful menu anchor

More than nine in ten respondents say pepperoni will never go out of style. Among the reported pepperoni pairings, sausage leads at 49%, followed by extra cheese at 30%, bacon at 27% and mushrooms at 27%.

Grocerant Guru® rating: A

Familiar favorites reduce the risk of menu experimentation. Pepperoni can anchor a core offering, while sausage, bacon and other complementary ingredients help create a more differentiated premium option.

Operators should test combinations against food cost, customer uptake and repeat orders rather than relying on popularity claims alone.

5. Meat-forward pizza has a defined audience

Twenty-seven percent of respondents identify as “Meat Maximalists,” and the survey says this preference appears across generations. The release also reports that 59% have experienced someone taking a slice of their meat-topped pizza after ordering a vegetarian pizza.

Grocerant Guru® rating: B+

Meat-forward options are worth testing, but a defined segment is not the entire market. A balanced lineup should retain vegetarian choices and allow customization.

Operators should also manage portions carefully. Ingredient appeal must translate into sustainable margins, and menu choices must reflect the needs of different households and occasions.

6. Regional identity can turn pizza into an experience

One-quarter of respondents seek regional pizza styles when traveling. Meanwhile, 82% of Gen Z respondents say they have participated in a friendly debate over which pizza style is best.

Grocerant Guru® rating: A−

Regional styles offer a way to create local relevance, storytelling and limited-time menus. The opportunity is to give customers something distinctive while preserving the consistency national chains need.

A regional product should be authentic enough to interest enthusiasts and accessible enough for mainstream customers. Operators should also consider whether regional offerings attract incremental visits instead of simply shifting customers away from existing menu items.

7. Pizza's competition extends beyond pizza chains

The 2026 Convenience Store News Foodservice Study, cited in the Smithfield Culinary release, reports that 76% of retailers offer pizza.

Grocerant Guru® rating: A

This is a significant channel signal. Consumers can encounter pizza in convenience stores, supermarkets, restaurants and other retail environments.

These channels compete for different occasions, price points and levels of convenience. A convenience-store customer seeking a quick individual meal has different needs from a family ordering several pizzas for dinner.

Pizza operators are no longer competing only with the pizzeria down the street. They are competing for the same meal occasion across an expanding range of foodservice and retail channels.

The grades in this analysis are my editorial assessments of each finding's usefulness for food marketing and menu strategy. They are not ratings assigned by Smithfield Culinary or measured consumer-satisfaction scores.

3. What Smithfield Culinary Gets Right—and What Operators Still Need to Prove

Smithfield Culinary makes a persuasive case for putting more thought into toppings. But from a food marketing perspective, the strongest opportunity is not simply to sell more meat. It is to turn a product preference into a repeatable, profitable customer occasion.

Three distinctions matter.

First, stated preference is not purchase behavior.

Saying toppings matter most does not tell us whether consumers will pay $2 more for premium sausage, switch brands for a specialty pizza or order that product a second time.

Operators need transaction data, menu-item sales, attachment rates and repeat-purchase measurements to establish those connections.

Second, quality must be visible and credible.

If a chain advertises premium ingredients but delivers an inconsistent product, the promise becomes a liability. Portion standards, preparation procedures and ingredient consistency must support the marketing claim.

Quality should be experienced, not just described.

Third, consumer value is larger than the pizza itself.

Price, quality, service, convenience and portability all shape the overall experience. A delicious pizza that arrives late, travels poorly or costs more than the household planned may not earn another order.

Even the largest chains must keep earning consumer business. Scale, brand recognition and digital ordering are advantages, but they do not eliminate the need to demonstrate value on every occasion.

The real question is not whether pizza is popular. It is whether a specific operator can convert that popularity into profitable, repeatable demand.

4. The Grocerant Guru® Consumer Challenge

Here is the test I would put to every pizza-chain executive and independent operator:

If a customer can buy pizza almost anywhere, what makes your pizza worth choosing, worth paying for and worth ordering again?

I would measure the answer through five practical indicators.

Trial: Are signature toppings, regional styles or new combinations bringing new customers into the brand?

Conversion: Do customers who see the offer actually purchase it?

Basket size: Does the new pizza increase the total order, or simply replace another menu item?

Frequency: Do customers return more often after trying it?

Profitability: Does the incremental margin justify the ingredients, labor, promotion and operational complexity?

These measures connect culinary creativity to business performance. They also help operators avoid a common mistake: assuming that a product with strong social-media appeal will necessarily become a reliable source of sales.

Pizza's advantage is its versatility. It can be a family dinner, an individual meal, a game-day centerpiece, a travel discovery, a workplace lunch or a convenient prepared-food purchase.

The challenge is to match the right product, portion, price and service model to each occasion.


Three Grocerant Guru® Insights on How the Pizza Sector Is Evolving

Insight 1: The next pizza battle is about differentiated value, not topping overload.

Smithfield Culinary's finding that 37% prioritize topping quality compared with 18% who prioritize quantity gives operators a reason to rethink premiumization.

The winning offer may be a carefully composed sausage-and-pepperoni pizza with excellent execution rather than an overloaded pie that raises food costs without increasing perceived value.

Test the premium, measure the repeat purchase and let consumers—not the chef's ego—decide.

Insight 2: Pizza is becoming an occasion-driven foodservice platform.

Traditional delivery and carryout remain important, but convenience stores and other retailers are competing for quick meals, snacks and immediate consumption.

Prepared pizza can serve a different need from a made-to-order family dinner. Operators should develop products and service formats around the occasion, considering portion size, holding time, packaging and speed instead of assuming every customer wants the same pizza experience.

This creates opportunities for both national chains and retailers that understand how consumers shop across foodservice channels.

Insight 3: Consumer loyalty will be earned one evolving occasion at a time.

The willingness to travel for pizza and the interest in regional styles show the potential for destination-worthy products. Yet frequency and convenience still matter.

Chains should pair reliable everyday favorites with distinctive regional offerings, limited-time products and digital ordering that makes repeat business easy.

Independent operators can compete through local identity and product character rather than trying to outspend national chains.

The challenge for every operator is to keep evolving without losing the core attributes that earned customer trust in the first place.

The Final Word from the Grocerant Guru®

The U.S. pizza sector is large, highly competitive and increasingly defined by more than store count.

Scale creates reach. Average unit volume helps measure sales productivity. Customer frequency helps reveal loyalty. Culinary differentiation creates a reason to choose one operator over another.

Smithfield Culinary's research adds an important message: toppings are a major opportunity, and consumers say quality matters more than simply piling on ingredients. But the business opportunity lies in connecting those preferences to actual behavior.

At Foodservice Solutions® in Tacoma, Washington, my perspective is straightforward: consumers are dynamic, not static. Their expectations, budgets, meal occasions and definitions of value evolve. The pizza operators that keep pace will be those that continuously test what consumers want, verify what they buy and measure whether they return.

A great pizza can earn a first order. A consistently great experience, delivered at the right price and for the right occasion, is what earns the next one.

Tap into the Foodservice Solutions® team for greater understanding of New Electricity or for a Grocerant Program Assessment, Grocerant ScoreCard, or for product positioning or placement assistance, or call our Grocerant Guru®.  Since 1991 www.FoodserviceSolutions.us  of Tacoma, WA has been the global leader in the Grocerant niche. Contact: Steve@FoodserviceSolutions.us or 253-759-7869



Thursday, October 15, 2026

Wendy’s Franchise Fight Raises a Bigger Question: Why Aren’t Franchisees Fighting Harder to Make the Brand Relevant Again?

 


A franchise agreement should be more than a license to display a familiar logo. It should be an investment in a brand that continually earns consumer attention, delivers compelling food, justifies its price, and gives customers a reason to return according to Steven Johnson, Grocerant Guru® Founder, at Tacoma, WA based Foodservice Solutions®.

Yet the Chapter 11 battle involving Wendy’s and one of its largest franchisees, Meritage Hospitality Group, raises a question that reaches well beyond bankruptcy court: Why are franchisees spending so much energy fighting over which restaurants to close when the industry needs an equally serious fight over how to make the restaurants worth visiting in the first place?

According to the supplied report, Meritage entered Chapter 11 after a difficult financial period, with additional restaurant closures under consideration and a dispute with Wendy’s over franchise terminations, potential damages, and which underperforming locations should shut down. Meritage’s restructuring team argues that keeping deeper-loss restaurants open undermines the purpose of its closure program. Wendy’s, meanwhile, argues that its preferred closures would better serve the overall restaurant portfolio.

Both parties have financial arguments to make. But from the perspective of the Grocerant Guru®, the larger strategic issue is what happens when a legacy brand’s consumer proposition fails to generate enough sales to support the economics of the franchise system.

Closing restaurants can reduce losses. It does not, by itself, rebuild consumer relevance.


The real question is whether franchisors and franchisees are working together aggressively enough to create more reasons for consumers to choose the brand, more often, at a price they believe is worth paying.

The numbers tell a story beyond bankruptcy

The figures in the supplied report illustrate the challenge facing Meritage and the broader strategic question facing Wendy’s.

The report states that Meritage was closing 41 additional restaurants across five groups, following 60 earlier closures. The 41 locations in the current closure process reportedly averaged $1.15 million in annual sales while losing approximately $127,000 per restaurant over the preceding 12 months.

Wendy’s proposed alternative list reportedly averaged $1.07 million in annual sales and lost approximately $114,000 per restaurant over the same period. The report also puts Wendy’s national average annual restaurant sales at approximately $2 million through 2025.

Those figures are reported numbers, not independently audited conclusions presented here. Nevertheless, the gap deserves attention.

If the figures are comparable, the restaurants under discussion are generating substantially less revenue than the reported systemwide average. That is a signal to investigate location economics, local competition, operating execution, consumer demand, and the strength of the brand proposition in each market.

The figures alone do not prove that Wendy’s brand messaging, food, pricing, or service caused those restaurants to underperform. Restaurant-level results can also reflect occupancy costs, labor expenses, traffic patterns, management, competition, and other market-specific factors.

But the strategic question remains: When a restaurant generates substantially less sales than the system average, what is the plan to make it more relevant to the consumer before the only remaining plan is to close it?


That question deserves just as much attention as the closure schedule.

1. Brand messaging: Familiarity is not the same as relevance

Wendy’s has a recognizable brand, a distinctive square hamburger, a long-standing fresh-beef message, and a history of irreverent advertising. Those are assets. But legacy brand equity is not a permanent guarantee of consumer preference.

Consumers do not buy a brand’s history. They buy what the brand delivers today.

Wendy’s own management acknowledged the need for change when it introduced Project Fresh on October 9, 2025. The plan called for strengthening brand positioning, improving marketing effectiveness, assessing the U.S. restaurant system, elevating the customer experience, and prioritizing average unit volume growth. The company specifically identified a need to connect more effectively with the next generation of customers..

That announcement is significant. It demonstrates that brand relevance and restaurant productivity are not simply complaints raised by struggling franchisees; they are issues Wendy’s corporate leadership has publicly identified as priorities.

The performance numbers add urgency. Wendy’s reported U.S. same-restaurant sales declined 5.6% for full-year 2025, following growth of 1.4% in 2024 and 3.7% in 2023. U.S. franchised restaurant average unit volume also declined, from approximately $2.086 million in 2024 to $1.984 million in 2025..

These results do not establish that advertising or messaging alone caused the decline. They do establish that a recognized national brand experienced a meaningful reversal in sales momentum.

The question for franchisees is straightforward: Are they getting the brand-building, marketing, menu innovation, and customer traffic support they need to compete effectively in their own markets?

Franchisees should demand measurable answers, not simply more promotional calendars.

They should ask corporate leadership to demonstrate which campaigns generate incremental visits, which messages convert younger customers, which promotions bring in new customers rather than discount existing purchases, and which marketing investments produce sustainable increases in restaurant-level sales.

A franchisee paying royalties and contributing to marketing funds should expect more than brand awareness. The objective is to generate profitable transactions.


2. Product: Does the menu fit the way consumers eat today?

The burger business has changed. Consumers still buy burgers, but they also compare chicken, snacks, beverages, breakfast, customizable meals, delivery options, and food that fits a particular occasion.

That is where the Grocerant Guru® perspective becomes important. Consumers increasingly construct meals across multiple channels and formats. A restaurant is not competing only with the burger restaurant across the street. It competes with convenience stores, supermarket prepared foods, delivery platforms, and other destinations offering quick, portable meal solutions.

The National Restaurant Association's 2025 off-premises research reported that nearly 75% of restaurant traffic occurred off-premises, including takeout, delivery, and drive-thru occasions. Its research also identified convenience, quality, and price as important considerations when customers choose off-premises meals..

That is a major consumer behavior signal. A brand must deliver more than a recognizable product. It must make the product easy to purchase, transport, eat, and justify economically.

Wendy’s has taken steps in this direction. In February 2025, the company outlined plans to expand chicken and beverage offerings, strengthen its Biggie Bag value platform, improve loyalty engagement, and continue breakfast innovation. Restaurant Dive reported that Wendy’s SpongeBob-themed Krabby Patty promotion produced a 20% same-store sales lift at its peak, according to company commentary.

That promotion offers an important lesson: a distinctive product-and-marketing combination can generate a measurable traffic response. It does not prove that every promotion will work or that the effect will persist after the promotion ends. It does show why franchisees should insist on a pipeline of relevant products and compelling reasons to visit.

Three product questions franchisees should push corporate leadership to answer:

·       Which menu innovations produce repeat purchases and incremental traffic, rather than a brief promotional spike?

·       How quickly can local operators test products that respond to regional tastes, emerging meal occasions, and competitive gaps?

·       Does the menu offer enough flexibility for consumers seeking affordable combinations, portable snacks, chicken, breakfast, and beverages throughout the day?

A franchisee should not have to accept a stagnant consumer proposition simply because the brand has a famous hamburger.


3. Price: Value is what customers receive, not just what they pay

Price competition is unavoidable. But discounting without a clear value proposition can weaken margins while failing to build loyalty.

The National Restaurant Association's 2025 industry outlook found that 47% of limited-service customers said their dining experience mattered more than price. The same report said 47% of restaurant operators planned to introduce new discounts, deals, or value promotions to attract traffic.

These findings point to a tension: affordability matters, but price is not the entire experience.

For Wendy’s, the challenge is to communicate why its food deserves the customer's money while offering price points that make sense for different budgets and occasions. A value meal must feel like a genuine solution, not a complicated calculation involving add-ons, app restrictions, or an offer that disappears before the customer can use it.

This is where franchisees should demand a better balance between national promotional strategy and local restaurant economics.

A corporate offer can produce more transactions and still leave the franchisee with insufficient incremental profit if food costs, labor, discounts, and transaction mix are not properly accounted for. Conversely, a well-designed combination can improve perceived value, increase attachment rates, and encourage customers to purchase more than a single item.

Franchisees should insist that promotional evaluations include:

·       Incremental transactions and repeat visits.

·       Average check and food-cost impact.

·       Profit contribution after discounts and labor.

·       New-customer acquisition versus subsidizing existing purchases.

·       Performance by daypart, market, and customer segment.

The objective should be to grow profitable unit sales, not simply to advertise a low price or defend market share.

4. Service: The promise is made at the drive-thru window

Brand messaging creates an expectation. Product delivers the promise. Price frames the value. Service determines whether the customer wants to repeat the experience.

A national advertising campaign cannot compensate indefinitely for inaccurate orders, inconsistent food, long waits, or an unfriendly interaction.

Wendy’s itself placed customer experience and operational execution among the priorities in its Project Fresh plan. Its investor-day strategy also emphasized more consistent execution, digital convenience, and improved hospitality..

That matters because service is not merely an expense to manage. It is part of the product the customer buys.

Franchisees should push for store-level reporting that connects speed, order accuracy, food quality, customer complaints, digital ordering, and repeat visits. They should also have a voice in determining whether corporate initiatives make operations easier or add complexity during already difficult service periods.

Three practical tests should be applied to every major operating change:

1.       Does it make ordering easier for the customer?

2.       Does it help employees deliver a more consistent experience?

3.       Does it increase repeat business or profitable transactions enough to justify the cost?

If the answer is no, the system should reconsider the change.

The important point is not to demand fewer standards. It is to demand standards that improve the customer experience and the economics of the restaurant together.


5. Why don't more franchisees demand a growth strategy?

The Meritage dispute illustrates a fundamental imbalance in franchising. Operators may invest their capital, hire employees, manage local execution, pay occupancy and operating costs, and absorb the consequences when customer traffic weakens. The franchisor controls important parts of the brand identity, national advertising, menu direction, franchise standards, and systemwide strategy.

That division of responsibility can create tension when results deteriorate.

In Meritage's case, the supplied report describes a legal fight over termination, approximately $147 million in asserted claims, and competing views about which restaurants should close. Those claims and the parties' legal positions remain disputed; they should not be mistaken for final judicial findings.

But the broader lesson is clear: Franchisees need a stronger voice in the strategic decisions that determine whether their restaurants can succeed.

Why should operators settle for defending their share of a shrinking or stagnant market when they could demand a credible plan to expand consumer demand?

Market share is not the same as market growth. A brand can maintain its share while the category weakens. It can also gain share while individual restaurants struggle with unprofitable sales, excessive costs, or poor local execution.

The better measure is whether the brand is winning more relevant occasions, increasing repeat visits, and generating sustainable average unit volume and restaurant-level profitability.

Franchisees should organize around common business objectives rather than waiting until financial distress forces them into individual disputes. Within their contractual and legal rights, they can press for transparent performance reporting, franchisee advisory participation, evidence-based marketing tests, product-development input, and clear accountability for systemwide growth initiatives.

They should also ask corporate leadership to report progress against measurable goals, including:

·       Same-store sales and transaction growth.

·       Average unit volume by comparable market and restaurant cohort.

·       Customer satisfaction, order accuracy, and service speed.

·       New-product trial and repeat-purchase performance.

·       Promotional return on investment and franchisee profitability.

·       Digital engagement that converts into profitable visits and orders.

Not every weak restaurant can be saved. Some locations have structural disadvantages that no campaign can overcome. Nor should a franchisor be expected to preserve every unit regardless of its economics.

But closing restaurants should be part of a comprehensive strategy, not a substitute for one.

The goal should be to distinguish restaurants that need operational improvement, restaurants that need a stronger consumer proposition, restaurants that need local market repositioning, and restaurants that genuinely need to close.

That is a much more useful conversation than arguing only over which locations disappear first.

The Grocerant Guru® bottom line: Fight for relevance, not just survival

Wendy’s has publicly acknowledged the need to strengthen brand positioning, improve the customer experience, and increase average unit volume. Its reported 2025 U.S. same-store sales decline demonstrates why those priorities matter.

For franchisees, the Meritage situation is a reminder that contractual rights and financial restructuring are important, but they cannot replace consumer demand.

The brand they bought must continue to earn its place in the consumer's consideration set. It must communicate a relevant promise, deliver compelling food, provide credible value, and make the experience worth repeating.

Franchisees should not accept market share as the ultimate measure of success. They should push for a brand that grows transactions, strengthens customer loyalty, and improves unit economics.


Three Grocerant Guru® Insights

1. Relevance drives the visit; value helps close the sale.

Consumers do not owe a legacy brand their loyalty. They reward brands that meet current needs with the right food, price, convenience, and experience. Franchisees should demand evidence that marketing investments turn relevance into repeat purchases and profitable sales.

2. A closure plan is not a consumer-growth plan.

Closing money-losing restaurants may be necessary, but it does not answer why consumers are choosing competitors. Every turnaround should distinguish between a bad location, poor execution, an outdated offer, and a brand that is losing relevance in a particular market.

3. Franchisees bought a business opportunity, not a museum piece.

A legacy brand's history is an asset only when it helps attract today's customers. Franchisees should push harder for better products, sharper messaging, credible pricing, stronger service, and measurable unit-sales growth. The objective is not merely to defend a share of the market. It is to make the brand more relevant to an evolving consumer and grow the business profitably.

Steven Johnson is the Grocerant Guru® and founder of Tacoma, Washington-based Foodservice Solutions®. His perspective focuses on the convergence of restaurants, grocery prepared foods, convenience retail, and evolving consumer meal occasions.