Rutter’s Elevating and Redefining Foodservice Model that Might Benefit All

 

For decades, convenience stores were synonymous with grab-and-go packaged snacks, cigarettes, and soft drinks. However, as consumer preferences shifted toward fresh, made-to-order food, the convenience store sector responded by elevating its food and beverage programs to compete directly with quick-service and full-service restaurants according to Steven Johnson Grocerant Guru® at Tacoma, WA based Foodservice Solutions®.

The shift began in earnest in the late 1990s and early 2000s when leading c-store chains introduced higher-quality coffee, expanded roller-grill selections, and incorporated made-to-order touchscreen kiosks. By the 2010s, competition intensified as convenience stores began offering freshly prepared meals, customizable beverage programs, and branded restaurant-style promotions. Today, c-stores are a dominant force in the foodservice industry, with prepared food sales exceeding $27 billion in 2024—a 42% increase since 2015.

Three Examples of How Convenience Stores Have Elevated Food & Beverage Offerings

1.       Sheetz & Touchscreen Customization: Sheetz pioneered made-to-order touchscreen ordering in the early 2000s, allowing customers to customize sandwiches, salads, and specialty coffee drinks, setting the stage for widespread digital ordering adoption in c-stores.

2.       Wawa & Fresh Food Expansion: Wawa has continually expanded its fresh food program, introducing handcrafted hoagies, fresh salads, and espresso-based beverages that rival café chains, leading to record customer loyalty and repeat visits.

3.       7-Eleven & Global Flavor Trends: Recognizing the consumer demand for international cuisine, 7-Eleven introduced Korean-style bulgogi wraps, Japanese onigiri, and Mexican street tacos, aligning with evolving taste preferences and driving new consumer trial.

Three Examples of Interactive & Participatory Marketing in Convenience Stores

1.       Casey’s & Customer-Driven Pizza Creations: Casey’s General Store, known for its pizza program, launched a ‘Create Your Own Pizza’ contest where customers could submit and vote on new pizza flavors, turning customer engagement into product innovation.

2.       Buc-ee’s & Social Media Buzz: Buc-ee’s has built a cult following by leveraging interactive social media challenges, customer-generated content, and limited-time flavor drops that drive foot traffic and online engagement.

3.       Kwik Trip & Rewards Gamification: Kwik Trip’s mobile app gamifies customer participation through fuel and food rewards, allowing users to earn points for purchases, spin digital prize wheels, and access exclusive meal deals.

Rutter’s: Driving Brand Value & Consumer Engagement

Rutter’s is taking convenience store innovation to the next level by integrating entertainment, interactive customer experiences, and premium foodservice offerings. The York, Pennsylvania-based chain, which operates 88 locations across Pennsylvania, Maryland, and West Virginia, is strategically investing in immersive retail experiences designed to capture the attention of consumers seeking both food and entertainment.

Four Reasons Rutter’s is Leading the Way

1.       Expanding into Sports Bar Concepts: Rutter’s is launching two 14,000-square-foot bar and lounge spaces in Pennsylvania, blurring the lines between convenience retail and casual dining by offering a selection of canned cocktails, beer, and wine alongside a high-energy sports viewing experience with over 20 65-inch TVs and real-time sports tickers.

2.       Leveraging Video Gaming & On-Premise Entertainment: In a move to drive foot traffic beyond traditional fuel and snack purchases, Rutter’s is integrating video gaming terminals, a strategy that has proven successful in increasing customer dwell time and incremental spending at hybrid c-store entertainment spaces.

3.       Elevating Made-to-Order Meal Customization: With a long history of menu innovation, Rutter’s continues to expand its foodservice offerings with fresh, made-to-order meals, positioning itself as a viable alternative to quick-service and casual dining restaurants.

4.       Redefining the Beverage Experience: Recognizing the growing demand for unique beverage experiences, Rutter’s beer caves, extensive craft selections, and self-serve beverage customization stations cater to the evolving preferences of today’s consumers.

The Future of C-Store Foodservice

The ongoing battle between convenience stores and restaurants is no longer just about speed and price—it’s about experience, quality, and consumer engagement. Rutter’s, along with other leading c-store chains, is proving that convenience retailers are not just competing with QSRs; they are actively redefining the boundaries of foodservice. As the Grocerant Guru® has long emphasized, customer-driven innovation and interactive engagement will continue to be the key drivers of success in the evolving convenience store sector.

Gain a Competitive Edge with a Grocerant ScoreCard

Unlock new opportunities with a Grocerant ScoreCard, designed to optimize product positioning, placement, and consumer engagement.

Since 1991, Foodservice Solutions® has been the global leader in the Grocerant niche—helping brands identify high-growth strategies that resonate with modern consumers.

📞 Call 253-759-7869 or 📩 Email Steve@FoodserviceSolutions.us